Does the Luscher Color Test Work

The Luscher color test is fun to take and fun to read its horoscope

4 Comments
Join the Conversation
luscher question - mary made
luscher question - mary made
The Max Luscher color test alleges to measure personality traits via a kind of test of color hierarchy. Do color tests work?

The Luscher color test is a psychological test that was created by Dr. Max Luscher. This test alleges to measure a person's ability to handle stress, to perform, and to communicate. The pre-determined test colors are said to measure 23 personality traits of the subject. The unconscious nature of choosing the order of color preference is supposed to provide all kinds of information about a person.

Color Personality Test

I enjoy giving this test to my students who are often surprised that their personality might be analyzed by color preference. But given the difference in color across cultures, I wonder how the Luscher color test would perform with a mixed audience from both east and west?

Color in Context

For example, in the west if you go to a funeral the traditional color of mourning is black. In the east, the color worn to funerals is white. So while the tester is asked not to associate clothing or other contexts with the color in question, I think it is impossible for us as humans to not contextualize color.

Taking the Color Test

As I go through the test I choose the brightest colors first. The first two colors I usually choose are orange and green. The message that this color combination sends is "You want to overcome the obstacles with which you are faced and to achieve special recognition from your success." Isn't this general and something everyone would say they desire? And all this from orange and green?

I always choose black and grey, respectively, as my least favorite colors. The test results of this color combination and order say "You want to overcome a feeling of emptiness and separation from others." Again, isn't this something we all feel at some time?

Does the Luscher Color Test Work?

In my opinion, the Luscher color test is a throw back to the day when people were prescribed to bathe in a certain color of light to achieve healing effects. The advent of penicillin led to the downfall of this quackery. If the Luscher color test is meant to be revealing about a person's personality, I think the Myers-Briggs personality test is much more effective and specific. I like the idea of a standard set of colors chosen in a particular order indicating personality, but the idea of the subconscious choice revealing anything meaningful seems unlikely.

Mary in her habitat, Doug Van Gundy

Mary Rayme - Mary Rayme is a graphic designer and arts educator with a BFA from the Maryland Institute College of Art in Baltimore.

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 8+2?

Comments

Feb 23, 2010 5:32 PM
Guest :
I took the Luscher Testsix times times over the course of a week.

On the first three consecutive days I followed the directions as they were given, and it yielded three different sets of results. Although there were similarities in certain areas of all three attempts, and some with which I was able to identify, some came off as being so general that they could apply to anyone.

Later, I took the test twice more. First, I made a conscious effort to choose colors in the opposite order than I preferred them. The second time, I chose them randomly, clicking colors very quickly without really paying any attention to them.

Both times gave different results again, but still showed a fair amount of the same generalities from my first three attempts, and which could apply to almost anyone.

Finally, I took the test as it had been presented using the "shockwave" animation format. Although this version was more visually appealing, and colors appeared clearer and brighter than before, I saw no improvement towards consistency of results. There was no 100 second delay as I had seen on other versions. The final results were different yet again, and this time I didn't recognize any personal characteristics, general or otherwise.

Mar 6, 2010 2:33 PM
Guest :
I took this test in a non-online version (the actual book version) and it gave me surprisingly accurate results. It said I needed to let my body rest (I had a repetitive-stress injury and a cold at the time), that I was feeling compromised because I was emotionally inhibited (I couldn't tell my friends to stop treating me like a doormat even though I was upset about it) and that I wanted to find someone who was equally sensitive as myself (which was also true--my friends treated me like a doormat because they aren't sensitive.)

So that was my experience.
Nov 14, 2010 8:31 PM
Guest :
I have to point out that "not likely" is an opinion, not a scientific statement in this case. A true test would be to have a group of people describe their emotional sate, and take the test, and see if it is possible to match the results to their own descriptions. I have given the test to many people, using the book, and several tried to give me random selections. I spotted them. I gave it to fellow high school students, and the people with good grades were usually very stress free, while the people who did not follow the rules so well had much higher stress. This is measured in the test in the book by certain colors being in certain areas of the order, for example green at the back or gray at the front. Ideally there is some judgment in interpretation, but only because those generalities that come up are not significant results based on these stress indicators.
In short, an opinion is not Science. Test your hypothesis.
Mar 19, 2012 11:47 AM
Guest :
Too much errors using and applying the test. First the test asks for choose colors in the context of the eight cards, not choosing colors as you like for your practical life. "I always choose...." - big error. Second, the test don“t give us "all kind of info..." the test give us something like a photo where the challenges and feeling in a moment. Third, there are no meanings of that cards, so intercultural meanings are meaningless !! The rainbow brings happyness to Apaches (USA) as to Aborigenes (Australia), and also to Twaregs (Egypt) and Anglo-saxons.!!
4 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement